Shower Temperature Fluctuates? Why Your Water Goes Hot and Cold (South Florida Guide)
If your shower temperature fluctuates, suddenly turning hot, then cold, then hot again, you’re not alone.
This is a common and frustrating problem for homeowners, and in some cases, it can even be dangerous, especially for children and older adults.
In South Florida homes, temperature swings are often caused by aging shower valves, water pressure changes, or problems inside the hot water system.
Let’s break down what’s actually causing it and how to fix it.
1. Failing Shower Mixing Valve (Most Common Cause)
Your shower uses a mixing valve to balance hot and cold water.
When the valve wears out:
- it can’t maintain consistent temperature
- pressure changes affect temperature
- hot water surges unexpectedly
- cold water suddenly dominates
Older valves (especially pre-1990s) are very prone to failure.
2. Someone Uses Water Elsewhere in the House
If your shower temperature changes when:
- a toilet flushes
- a sink turns on
- the washing machine starts
…it usually means your plumbing system isn’t pressure-balanced.
Modern pressure-balancing valves prevent this. Older systems do not.
3. Water Heater Issues
Temperature fluctuations can also originate at the water heater.
Common heater-related causes:
- sediment buildup reducing heat consistency
- failing thermostat
- undersized water heater
- heating element cycling improperly
In South Florida, mineral-heavy water causes sediment to build up quickly, making this more common.
4. Low or Fluctuating Water Pressure
Changes in pressure affect how much hot vs cold water reaches the shower.
Causes include:
- failing pressure reducing valve (PRV)
- partially closed shutoff valves
- pipe restrictions from corrosion
- municipal pressure changes
Pressure problems often show up first in showers.
5. Tankless Water Heater Limitations
If you have a tankless system, temperature swings can happen when:
- flow rate is too low
- multiple fixtures run at once
- the unit is scaled internally
- sensors misread demand
Tankless systems require proper sizing and regular maintenance.
6. Why This Is a Safety Issue
Sudden temperature changes can cause:
- scalding
- slips and falls
- burns
- discomfort and stress
Children and seniors are especially vulnerable.
If water suddenly turns very hot, it should be addressed immediately.
7. Why This Happens More in South Florida
South Florida homes often have:
- older plumbing systems
- aging shower valves
- mineral-heavy water
- higher water pressure
- fast sediment buildup in heaters
All of these contribute to unstable shower temperatures.
8. DIY Checks You Can Do
You can test:
✔ whether temperature changes when other fixtures run
✔ hot vs cold pressure at other sinks
✔ age of the shower valve
✔ age of the water heater
If the issue is consistent, it’s not user error.
9. Why Adjusting the Handle Doesn’t Fix It
Turning the handle back and forth only masks the problem temporarily.
If the valve internals are worn, temperature instability will continue, and often worsen over time.
10. When to Call a Plumber
Call a professional if:
- temperature swings happen daily
- water suddenly turns very hot
- multiple showers are affected
- the home has older plumbing
- the water heater is 8+ years old
- pressure changes occur throughout the house
These indicate system-level issues.
11. What We Do (Professional Solution)
At Leading Plumbing Services, we:
- inspect shower valves
- test pressure balance
- replace failing mixing valves
- inspect water heater performance
- flush sediment buildup
- test pressure regulation
- restore safe, consistent temperature
We fix the cause , not just the symptom.
12. Long-Term Prevention
To prevent future temperature swings:
✔ upgrade to pressure-balancing valves
✔ maintain your water heater yearly
✔ address pressure issues early
✔ replace aging plumbing components
Preventive upgrades improve comfort and safety.
Final Thoughts
If your shower temperature fluctuates, it’s a sign your plumbing system can’t properly balance hot and cold water.
Fixing it early:
- improves comfort
- prevents scalding
- protects your plumbing
- avoids emergency repairs
Call/Text us today for shower temperature diagnostics and repair:
(561) 506-6159





