Toilet Keeps Running? Why It Happens, What It’s Costing You, and How to Fix It

If your toilet keeps running, it’s not just an annoying background noise, it’s one of the most common and expensive plumbing problems homeowners ignore.
A running toilet can quietly waste thousands of gallons of water per month, driving up your water bill and stressing your plumbing system.
In South Florida, running toilets are especially common due to mineral-heavy water, aging toilet components, and high humidity that accelerates wear inside the tank.
Let’s break down what’s really happening and why fixing it sooner rather than later matters.
1. What “Running” Actually Means
A running toilet isn’t always obvious.
It may:
- refill every few minutes
- make a faint hissing sound
- run silently into the bowl
- cycle on and off by itself
Many homeowners don’t notice it until the water bill spikes.
2. Worn Flapper (Most Common Cause)
The flapper seals water inside the tank.
Over time, flappers:
- warp
- harden
- crack
- collect mineral buildup
When the flapper doesn’t seal properly, water slowly leaks from the tank into the bowl , triggering constant refilling.
South Florida’s mineral content shortens flapper lifespan significantly.
3. Faulty Fill Valve
The fill valve controls how water enters the tank.
When it fails:
- it doesn’t shut off completely
- water continues flowing
- the tank overfills slightly
- excess water escapes into the overflow tube
This creates a continuous or intermittent running sound.
4. Improper Water Level
If the water level in the tank is set too high:
- water spills into the overflow tube
- the fill valve keeps activating
- the toilet never fully “rests”
This is a simple adjustment , but it’s often overlooked.
5. Chain or Flapper Interference
Something as small as the chain can cause big problems.
If the chain:
- is too short
- gets tangled
- wedges under the flapper
…the flapper can’t seal, and the toilet runs continuously.
6. Cracked Overflow Tube
A cracked or damaged overflow tube can:
- allow water to bypass the flapper
- cause constant refilling
- require replacement of internal components
This is more common in older toilets.
7. How Much Water a Running Toilet Wastes
This surprises most homeowners.
A running toilet can waste:
- 200–300 gallons per day
- 6,000–9,000 gallons per month
- 70,000+ gallons per year
That’s money literally going down the drain.
8. Why This Is So Common in South Florida
Running toilets are more frequent here because:
- minerals degrade rubber parts faster
- humidity accelerates component wear
- older homes still use outdated toilet internals
- sediment buildup interferes with seals
Many toilets fail years earlier than expected.
9. DIY Checks You Can Do Right Now
You can safely check:
β remove the tank lid and observe refilling
β listen for hissing when not in use
β add food coloring to the tank (without flushing)
β watch for color entering the bowl
β check if the handle sticks
If dye appears in the bowl → the flapper is leaking.
10. Why Ignoring a Running Toilet Is Risky
Beyond higher bills, running toilets can:
- stress the fill valve until it fails completely
- cause internal leaks
- waste treated drinking water
- mask larger plumbing issues
- hide pressure problems
It’s a small fix that prevents bigger problems.
11. When Replacement Makes More Sense
Sometimes replacing parts isn’t enough.
Replacement is often recommended if:
- toilet is 15+ years old
- multiple components are failing
- cracks are present
- parts are no longer compatible
- water efficiency is poor
Modern toilets use far less water and perform better.
12. What We Do (Professional Repair)
At Leading Plumbing Services, we:
- diagnose the exact cause
- replace worn flappers and valves
- adjust water levels properly
- test for silent leaks
- inspect tank integrity
- recommend upgrades when needed
- ensure the toilet shuts off completely
We stop the water waste , permanently.
13. Prevention Tips
To prevent running toilets:
β replace flappers every few years
β avoid harsh tank cleaners
β address mineral buildup early
β listen for silent refilling
β upgrade outdated toilet internals
Preventive maintenance saves water and money.
South Florida Homeowner Reality
In South Florida, a toilet that keeps running is one of the most common causes of unexplained high water bills, and one of the easiest problems to fix when caught early.
Most homeowners wait too long.
Final Thoughts
If your toilet keeps running, it’s costing you money every day , even if you don’t hear it.
Fixing it now is one of the fastest ways to lower your water bill and protect your plumbing system.
Call/Text us today for toilet repair or replacement:
ο»Ώ
(561) 506-6159





